On April 26, 2025, VTuber model artist Nanoless (ナノレス) publicly announced the end of her collaboration with fellow streamer Sinder (シンダー), revealing troubling allegations involving Sinder’s manager (referred to as REDACTED). According to Nanoless, she was pressured into signing exclusive agreements, discouraged from working with others, and was subjected to emotional and professional coercion. The accusations included blacklist threats, behind-the-scenes manipulation, and verbal pressure that deeply impacted her ability to work freely.
The situation escalated quickly, prompting widespread discussion within the VTuber community. On April 28, Sinder responded by publishing a 7-page apology titled “My Apology.” In the document, she admitted to allowing possessiveness and personal attachment to override professional boundaries. She apologized to Nanoless, Bao, Shylily, Vampeaches, and others affected, and confirmed that REDACTED would no longer act as her manager.
Sinder’s apology detailed her emotional dependency on Nanoless, her failure to recognize her manager’s manipulative influence, and the toll of burnout and insecurity on her judgment. She confessed to fostering resentment toward fellow creators, including Silvervale and Bao, without verifying facts, and acknowledged neglecting friendships and mismanaging collaborative relationships. She also publicly apologized to her fanbase, collaborators, and even her former partner Rayne for past personal misconduct unrelated to the current controversy.
The apology sparked mixed reactions. While some appreciated her directness and accountability, others criticized the statement as deflective and incomplete. Influential figures like Shylily and Tectone publicly denounced the apology, while fan forums such as r/VirtualYoutubers hosted long threads dissecting both Nanoless’s initial post and Sinder’s response.
This incident has quickly become one of the most talked-about controversies in the VTuber space this year. It reveals the structural vulnerabilities in the virtual entertainment industry, where friendships, contracts, and power dynamics often overlap without clear boundaries. Fans and creators alike are now calling for more transparent ethical standards, better support systems for talent, and clearer separation between personal and professional conduct.
Sinder concluded her apology by stating that she does not expect forgiveness, but she is committed to becoming better. Whether the community chooses to accept that effort remains uncertain.
